Monday, October 13, 2008
Pointing the Finger
Okay--so i was just watching Law and Order SVU, and lo and behold-it somehow connected back to American Studies, crazy! The episode was framed around a nine-year-old girl who had been molested. The SVU team (Police officers specialized in the "special victims unit"-typically cases concerning rape, assault, or murder.) questioned her about it and at first she refused to tell, but under pressure she finally blurted out that it had been her soccer coach. After this first accusation, the SVU team decided it would be best to question the other girls on the soccer team about the coach as well. In the waiting room of the station, there was complete hysteria. The girls all sat with their paranoid parents--who continued to ask them questions over and over about the coach with the correct answer already in mind. Most of the girls said no at first, however soon enough confessions started rolling out. As the detectives sat them down individually to ask questions, all the girls replied with the same basic story; that they had been molested by the soccer coach and that they were told not to tell anyone. When the DNA samples came back however, it turned out that the real criminal was the original girl's neighbor. The soccer coach was completely clean; however under the pressure of the questioning, the girls had given in and told their parents the story they wanted to hear. This reminded me so much of the Crucible when people were asked who they saw with the devil. If they accused someone else of trafficking with the devil, then the pressure was off of them. Of course, the little girls were not going to get in trouble for saying they weren't raped; however it seemed that admitting to being assaulted was the only way to stop the frenzied questioning. It brings to attention how universal this really is. During perilous times, people are desperate for some sort of closure, some sort of solution to the problem--even if it means falsly accusing somebody of rape or witchcraft. It's so much easier to point the finger rather then confront the problem head on.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
Relating American Studies back to a show like SVU, just illustrates how universal blame really is and how it can show up almost everywhere. Even though in the SVU case it was obvious that the girls would not be in danger if they didn't make this claim, they were more susceptible to pressure because they are children and were not entirely clear on what would happen to them if they didn't give in and blame. Paralleling to the girls of the Salem Trials both groups were children and just wanted the questioning to stop at any cost. Unlike adults it could be argued that those children didn’t have the consequences of their actions in mind and just wanted the immediate effect of being left alone, unlike adults who would have had more life experience to understand that they would not be in trouble with the case of SVU.
Post a Comment